I love these little cigars too much, so much in fact that I put up with more and more unsmokable sticks in every shipment. This isn’t Atlantic Cigars fault but the QC at Hoya but that doesn’t stop me from getting mad every time I light a stick that doesn’t draw.

Best little cigar on the market, they have the taste and smoke of a larger size and are very convenient. I’ve been smoking them for longer than I care to admit and I have looked for alternatives many times due to their inconsistent quality. Invariably there’s 2-5 sticks per tin have issues sometimes more but I have yet to find another little cigar that I like as well. As to Atlantic Cigar I have always had fast shipping and excellent customer service.

Cheaper than any quality cigar, and better quality than any cheap cigar. Best daily driver I have found. (They seem identical to the Punch cigarillos of the same size.) Docking one star because of the occasional quality issue like peeling wrappers or breaks that prevent a proper draw. Even so, the failure rate is low enough that the net cost/benefit is still the best.

First, I have found that Atlantic Cigar consistently has the best prices and fast shipping. 5 Stars for them. Second, the Hoyo De Monterrey Excalibur Cigarillos are my favorite in terms of flavor. Mild with body and smooth throughout. Now the bad, in recent years the Quality Control seems to have slipped a good deal. I realize these are machine made, but they are much less consistent with issues running from some being so loose and dry they come apart right out of the tin to being rolled so tight they will not draw, holes in the wrapper, cracked, etc. It's hit or miss, some tins are pretty good all the way through with 1 or 2, but others have as many 5-6 bad sticks. The average overall is probably 3-4 bas sticks per tin. Despite the QC issues, they are still my choice in a cigarillo over all. 4 Stars for them.